the ethical, moral and health hazards of transplant tourism


Now that’s a mighty long title – for a very small section of medical tourism, which alternates in generating world-wide headlines and being swept quietly under the rug.

Bathtub full of ice

Everyone has heard ‘urban folklore’ regarding the unwary/ drunken/ duped young man who goes looking for sex, and wakes up in a bathtub full of ice.. Conventional wisdom is that these tales serve as a modern-day fairy tale with an underlying moral message.  In this case – cautioning young people against the vices of alcohol/ drugs and anonymous/ promiscuous sex..  If only the truth were really just such a cautionary tale. But, as readers know, the truth is considerably darker – involving the exploitation and even outright murder of citizens around the world to feed the organ trade.

(For the first-person account from a Chinese doctor involved in organ harvesting, click here. )

“Transplant Tourism”

This division of medical tourism, “Transplant tourism“,  is the sanitized term for organ selling, or diversion of transplantable organs to wealthy consumers (outside of the formal donor networks like UNOS).

Transplant tourism/ murder for organs is making headlines again this week as Taiwanese legislators try to ban the practice among their citizens and residents.  The Taiwanese lawmakers are trying to prevent the practice of wealthy patients (and companies making money from the sale of organs/ transplantation) using China as a ‘spare parts’ playground.

As widely reported over the last several years – China has become notorious for widespread ethical violations, including the murder (execution) of political prisoners for organ sales and transplantation to wealthy buyers.  Many of these political prisoners are people accused of such crimes as the practice of the religion, Falun Gong, or for expressing ideas that challenge the traditional Chinese culture or current government practices.

Not illegal in the United States

Unfortunately, despite multiple scientific, medical, governmental papers and sporadic media coverage of this issue – it is not illegal for Americans to engage in this practice, nor for American companies to offer transplantation services based on these practices.  (It is illegal for organs to be sold in the USA, but not for people to travel to engage in these practices.) While the United Nations, New Zealand, Australia and now, Taiwan have begun addressing this practice – the US government remains silent.

Protecting citizens from the wealthy foreigner

Other nations, like Pakistan have acted to try to prevent their citizens from becoming donor sources for wealthy foreigners.  Just today, a new law was passed to prevent organs obtained in Pakistan from being given to non-Pakistani residents. While these laws will not eliminate the practice outright, these countries and their citizens have taken a moral and legal stance against the practices. Now, it’s our turn.

Resources/ More information on this topic

More about the people “criminals” the Chinese government is executing – and taking organs from – Washington Post, November 2012

List of famous Chinese dissidents – Wikipedia

More about the murder and torture of practitioners of Falun Gong

The Ugly Side of Medical Tourism – a related post with links to scholarly articles and media reports regarding transplant tourism in China and Latin America.

A look at why transplant tourism is not safe for recipients, either.

Patients with passports – another post on law, ethics and medical tourism discussion focused on the publication of a book by the same title.  Includes links to several articles by Dr. Delmonico – the foremost  expert on illegal organ transplantation.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “the ethical, moral and health hazards of transplant tourism

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s